Mystery Island: Winner Takes All is a thrilling mystery movie that will be released by Hallmark Mystery on March 13, 2025. Directed and written by John Christian Plummer, the film stars Kristin Booth and Elizabeth Henstridge in key roles.
The story revolves around a group of people who win a trip to a mysterious island, where they are tasked with solving a fake murder mystery to win a large prize. However, things take a chilling turn when a real worker is found dead, and hidden secrets begin to unfold.
The group must quickly solve the crime before more danger arises, leading to an exciting and suspense-filled plot.
Where Was Mystery Island: Winner Takes All Filmed?
The filming of Mystery Island: Winner Takes All took place in Panama, Central America, primarily in Playa Bonita. Known for its beautiful beaches and stunning views of the Pacific Ocean, this location provided the perfect backdrop for the movie’s suspenseful and mysterious atmosphere.
Another significant filming location for the movie was Casa Naga, a luxurious villa in Playa Bonita, which offered a high-end, tropical retreat, perfect for capturing the film’s mysterious vibe.
Playa Bonita, Panama, Central America

The main filming location was Playa Bonita, located near Panama City, known for its scenic beauty, tranquil environment, and proximity to the Panama Canal. It’s a popular spot for luxury resorts, making it ideal for setting the movie’s mysterious tone. The beautiful landscape and peaceful surroundings also added a sense of isolation, which made the storyline even more intriguing.
Casa Naga, Playa Bonita, Panama, Central America
Another key location was Casa Naga, a luxury villa in Playa Bonita, also known as Villa Bonita Mansion. Casa Naga is known for its stunning views of the Panama Canal and blends Balinese architecture with local Panamanian culture. The villa’s elegant design and luxurious feel made it the perfect setting for many of the film’s dramatic scenes.
When Did the Filming of Mystery Island: Winner Takes All Take Place?
Filming for Mystery Island: Winner Takes All began in October 2024. The crew spent several weeks in the tropical setting of Panama, capturing the film’s suspenseful and dramatic moments against the stunning backdrop of Playa Bonita and Casa Naga.
To make your search for Mystery Island: Winner Takes All filming locations more funny and enjoyable, here’s a behind-the-scenes photo for you to enjoy. Take a closer look at what went on during filming!
In Late 2024 in the Month of December movie star Charlie Weber shared a behind the scene post on his Instagram account:-
Official Trailer of Mystery Island: Winner Takes All
The official trailer for Mystery Island: Winner Takes All was released on the Hallmark Channel’s YouTube channel a couple of weeks ago. Fans of Hallmark Mystery can watch it to get a glimpse of the movie’s exciting twists and turns, as well as the stunning locations featured in the film.
FAQs
Q: Where was Mystery Island: Winner Takes All filmed?
A: The movie was filmed in Playa Bonita, Panama, Central America, particularly at Casa Naga, a luxurious villa in the area.
Q: When did filming for Mystery Island: Winner Takes All take place?
A: Filming began in October 2024.
Q: Is there a trailer for Mystery Island: Winner Takes All?
A: Yes, the official trailer for the movie was shared on the Hallmark Channel’s YouTube channel a few weeks ago.
Q: Why was Playa Bonita chosen for filming?
A: Playa Bonita’s beautiful beaches, serene environment, and proximity to the Panama Canal made it an ideal location for capturing the film’s mysterious and suspenseful atmosphere.
Q: When will Mystery Island: Winner Takes All be released?
A: The movie will be released on March 13, 2025, by Hallmark Mystery.